I completed
Final Fantasy 7 Remake Intergrade INTERmission (and will not miss this final opportunity to write out it's stupid name). That was actually quite good. Focused, with a much refined and more interesting spin on the FF7R combat mechanics. Not overstaying it's welcome - it's actually the only game in recent memory where I finished it and thought it could be a bit longer.
I fear that a lot of what I found good about it are things that only happened due to its status as a focused side chapter, and that SE will throw all that out the window with Rebirth. But I am curious. Oh, and the PC port is still extremely barebones.
I then finally found
Octopath Traveller at a price I was willing to pay. 12 hours in:
The good
- The individual stories are mostly pretty decent.
- Interesting out-of-combat skill use mechanics (especially for a JRPG), which also tie into some side quests.
- Pacing is to my liking so far - the relative time spent exploring, on story, on combat and on other stuff is quite balanced.
- Great music.
The Meh
- I know some people find value in it, but random combat just isn't for me any more. If I hadn't (by luck) chosen the protagonist who very early on gets a passive skill to greatly reduce encounter frequency I might've dropped the game already.
- Some of the randomness-based skills really encourage degenerate gameplay / save scumming. When you introduce something like that with clear inspiration from CRPGs, then maybe also look at the decades of design development to deal with that.
The Ugly
- There is absolutely zero reason for the party mechanics being what they are. I can almost always freely switch party members, and making me go through a drawn out process to do this whenever I need a specific skill is not gameplay. It's just meaningless make-work with no player agency or value.
- The fact that the characters don't interact on a story level at all is a massive detriment to the game, and completely prevents it from reaching it's full potential. Sure, it would need a bit more writing that not everyone might see, but the payoff would be more than worth it.