Roughly a week after the whole GPUcalypse and me burning out of hardware, let me ask some actual proper questions about what happened, because I'm clueless but y'all probably aren't.
Recap of the last 12365465 episodes
Before: I had a fairly old rig (i5-4440, GTX 780, PSU XFX 80+ bronze 650w). It was working fine.
After: I upgraded to a Ryzen 3600, mobo Tomahawk Max, 2080 Super, and some Corsair LPX RAM.
It worked for a few days, then it wouldn't boot anymore.
The mobo beep code seemed to complain about the GPU, but I tried it on the old rig, and it seemed to work fine.
I've replaced mobo and CPU, and everything worked fine, finally.
Latest episode
In fact, the new rig was working almost fine.
Sometimes it booted to a black screen, requiring me to restart to get a video signal. Sometimes it booted to the wrong resolution, just to switch to the correct one after a few seconds in Windows.
Since everything else was satisfying (especially the in-game performances, e.g. with RDR2 at 4K@30fps at almost max settings), I blamed it all to the fact that I didn't reinstall Win after changing from Intel to AMD etc.
Aside those issues, I really had no reasons to doubt my GPU.
Until at some point, while scrolling Twitter, I noticed that some videos were showing odd artifacts.
I investigated it a bit, and figured that MP4 files were pixelated and pink/blue/purple, while WEBM were very trippy.
I've only grabbed a screenshot of the Steam Sale homepage (a WEBM), and unfortunately I can't find any screens I've grabbed of the broken MP4 files.
Trippy version:
Original for comparison:
Even so, I blamed it to Chrome, or some broken Win codecs.
Until, after about 20 hours into RDR2, it crashed with the infamous ERR_GFX_STATE code, which, according to Rockstar and the internet as a whole, can mean anything or nothing at all.
I tried all the known workarounds, reinstalling the Nvidia drivers from scratch, and I've even reinstalled Win for good measure.
RDR2 kept crashing (always), and MP4/WEBM files kept being broken (often but not always).
At that point, I tried some other games:
Metro Exodus: never tried before, crashed with DX12 (for the raytracing stuff), worked with DX11.
The Outer Worlds: never tried before, crashed with DX12/Vulkan, worked with DX11 (I think? I can't really remember this test, but I'm sure it crashed on load)
Civ 6: played for countless hours, up to a week before, crashed with DX12, worked with DX11.
Tried reinstalling the drivers one more time, then removed the 2080 Super, and tried with the old 780.
The 780 doesn't support DX12 for realsies, so I couldn't do a proper 1:1 comparison.
But of course, everything worked fine. Even RDR2.
Tried again with the 2080 Super (just in case), and of course everything crashed again.
So, I've sent the 2080 Super back to Amazon (bless Amazon and its no questions asked replacement policy), and at the moment I'm playing with the 780 (which is super sad after trying 4K freesync ) and waiting for getting the big bag of cash back into my bank account.
In the next episode
The initial plan was to just stop buying shit and be content of what I had.
That didn't last long!
But before I try to buy a new 2080 Super (I'm looking at an MSI, which is the same model I've replaced, and a Gigabyte, both at an appropriate price point), I need to be 100% sure it was an actual GPU problem.
Could it be a RAM issue? The Corsair I bought needs to enable the XMP profile to run at full speed (3200) on my mobo. Could it cause any issues?
The PSU has seen better days: a few months ago I've had to open it because a cable inside was touching the fan. Aside from that I've had literally zero reasons to believe it's failing. Like, the PC never shut down unexpectedly and whatnot.
Is there any way that I was running RDR2 at... more than what my system allowed... and so I blew up something?
Do y'all have any tests to recommend that I can use to double check my components?
Recap of the last 12365465 episodes
Before: I had a fairly old rig (i5-4440, GTX 780, PSU XFX 80+ bronze 650w). It was working fine.
After: I upgraded to a Ryzen 3600, mobo Tomahawk Max, 2080 Super, and some Corsair LPX RAM.
It worked for a few days, then it wouldn't boot anymore.
The mobo beep code seemed to complain about the GPU, but I tried it on the old rig, and it seemed to work fine.
I've replaced mobo and CPU, and everything worked fine, finally.
Latest episode
In fact, the new rig was working almost fine.
Sometimes it booted to a black screen, requiring me to restart to get a video signal. Sometimes it booted to the wrong resolution, just to switch to the correct one after a few seconds in Windows.
Since everything else was satisfying (especially the in-game performances, e.g. with RDR2 at 4K@30fps at almost max settings), I blamed it all to the fact that I didn't reinstall Win after changing from Intel to AMD etc.
Aside those issues, I really had no reasons to doubt my GPU.
Until at some point, while scrolling Twitter, I noticed that some videos were showing odd artifacts.
I investigated it a bit, and figured that MP4 files were pixelated and pink/blue/purple, while WEBM were very trippy.
I've only grabbed a screenshot of the Steam Sale homepage (a WEBM), and unfortunately I can't find any screens I've grabbed of the broken MP4 files.
Trippy version:
Original for comparison:
Even so, I blamed it to Chrome, or some broken Win codecs.
Until, after about 20 hours into RDR2, it crashed with the infamous ERR_GFX_STATE code, which, according to Rockstar and the internet as a whole, can mean anything or nothing at all.
I tried all the known workarounds, reinstalling the Nvidia drivers from scratch, and I've even reinstalled Win for good measure.
RDR2 kept crashing (always), and MP4/WEBM files kept being broken (often but not always).
At that point, I tried some other games:
Metro Exodus: never tried before, crashed with DX12 (for the raytracing stuff), worked with DX11.
The Outer Worlds: never tried before, crashed with DX12/Vulkan, worked with DX11 (I think? I can't really remember this test, but I'm sure it crashed on load)
Civ 6: played for countless hours, up to a week before, crashed with DX12, worked with DX11.
Tried reinstalling the drivers one more time, then removed the 2080 Super, and tried with the old 780.
The 780 doesn't support DX12 for realsies, so I couldn't do a proper 1:1 comparison.
But of course, everything worked fine. Even RDR2.
Tried again with the 2080 Super (just in case), and of course everything crashed again.
So, I've sent the 2080 Super back to Amazon (bless Amazon and its no questions asked replacement policy), and at the moment I'm playing with the 780 (which is super sad after trying 4K freesync ) and waiting for getting the big bag of cash back into my bank account.
In the next episode
The initial plan was to just stop buying shit and be content of what I had.
That didn't last long!
But before I try to buy a new 2080 Super (I'm looking at an MSI, which is the same model I've replaced, and a Gigabyte, both at an appropriate price point), I need to be 100% sure it was an actual GPU problem.
Could it be a RAM issue? The Corsair I bought needs to enable the XMP profile to run at full speed (3200) on my mobo. Could it cause any issues?
The PSU has seen better days: a few months ago I've had to open it because a cable inside was touching the fan. Aside from that I've had literally zero reasons to believe it's failing. Like, the PC never shut down unexpectedly and whatnot.
Is there any way that I was running RDR2 at... more than what my system allowed... and so I blew up something?
Do y'all have any tests to recommend that I can use to double check my components?