|OT| Elden Ring - Foul Tarnished, in search of the Elden Ring

Panda Pedinte

Best Sig Maker on the board!
Sep 20, 2018
4,975
13,724
113
I finally finished it!

Clocked 150h on that save though there were a lot of hours where I was just away doing chores around the house. I explored a lot and even though I did not even farm my character ended being level 163 if I'm not mistaken. There are some achievements that I missed and I keep some save backups so I may go back to get the different endings.
 

Avern

MetaMember
May 14, 2020
370
1,239
93
Question: Is there anything that can lock you out of endings? I normally platinum these games with 3-4 playthroughs, but with how insanely long Elden Ring is, I think I'd rather grab them in one go with save backups.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Panda Pedinte

Panda Pedinte

Best Sig Maker on the board!
Sep 20, 2018
4,975
13,724
113
Question: Is there anything that can lock you out of endings? I normally platinum these games with 3-4 playthroughs, but with how insanely long Elden Ring is, I think I'd rather grab them in one go with save backups.
There is an event that locks you out of two endings but is required for the other ending.

I recommend keeping some save backups if you want to do all the endings in a same playthrough.
 
  • Love
Reactions: Avern

EdwardTivrusky

Good Morning, Weather Hackers!
Dec 8, 2018
7,447
12,579
113
I think i'm a bit late for that, i've got a feeling i;m on a certain path but i'll carry on and check guides for my next run. Probably dig out my save file monitor script to get autobackups sorted. Depends on how frequent the saves are tho, i might do it manually just to keep notes in OneNote as to what save contains what triggers etc.

edit: by that time there should be some good clear guides to endings and decision impacts and links too.
 

QFNS

Plays too many card games
Nov 18, 2018
1,308
3,153
113
I'm really glad I decided to sidetrack a bit and do Ranni's quest. The Eternal Cities are gorgeous to look at and great fun to explore.
I did this tonight. Some really amazing areas here. I can't believe these are totally missable! Insane that so much art and so many unique enemies would be put here. FROM is truly out of their minds in the best way.
 

Li Kao

It’s a strange world. Let’s keep it that way.
Jan 28, 2019
7,906
16,001
113
I feel really let down by From with this game. The whole difficulty thing is subjective and personal. The quality of the open world too, and I’m not saying it’s without merits, I clocked 100+ hours like a zombie on it.
But seeing the dev patch in quest chains is souring a little. I mean, From are not know for their technical prowess, but broken quests is a new low.
You could argue that it comes with the territory in this always updated, never totally finished game landscape, but really, you ship your game without checking the quest chains ?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Panda Pedinte

fantomena

MetaMember
Dec 17, 2018
9,876
26,620
113
Just reached 60 hours on Steam, still not done and have a lot more to discover. Steam says DS3 took me 66 hours and I did 3 playthroughs on that time.
 
  • Evil
Reactions: Panda Pedinte

toxicitizen

MetaMember
Oct 24, 2018
1,655
4,232
113
Been revisiting crypts to find those "secret ahead" messages that Ive seen so often, of course I don't find them anymore!T_T
I think if a message is downvoted enough it disappears eventually. I've started coming across lots of "liar ahead" messages a little distance from walls but with no other message between them and the wall lol.
 

xinek

日本語が苦手
Apr 17, 2019
781
1,442
93
I ruthlessly disparage messages -- trolls about hidden walls or jump to your death spots, any "but hole", "dog", "fort, nite" or "pickle" joke. Anything overdone. So tired of the same stupid crap. There's a place for that stuff, but the overwhelming amount of it in this game is due to its popularity, I guess. I suppose I hate fun.
 

Arc

MetaMember
Sep 19, 2020
3,030
11,435
113
Late game boss rant:

Malenia's lifesteal completely ruins the fight and makes her unfun. I like her patterns, but the lifesteal mechanic is just terrible.
 

Panda Pedinte

Best Sig Maker on the board!
Sep 20, 2018
4,975
13,724
113
Late game boss rant:

Malenia's lifesteal completely ruins the fight and makes her unfun. I like her patterns, but the lifesteal mechanic is just terrible.


The lifesteal can be really annoying in that fight.

I used Black Knife Tiche spirit summon as she has an attack that apply a temporary debuff to the enemy, she also can avoid some Malenia's attacks.
 
  • Like
Reactions: QFNS and Arc

Alextended

Segata's Disciple
Jan 28, 2019
5,750
8,999
113
Oh neat, out of the blue Nepheli got unstuck from the council basement and her quest line progressed (finished?). Must have been a patch that did it. Would have been nicer if it occured way earlier in the game than this random point 100 hours later without doing anything new to trigger it but oh well.
 

yuraya

MetaMember
May 4, 2019
2,814
6,442
113
So, those of you who've been souls lovers since day one, how do you feel now that ER has so many casual fans? Are you hipster bitter ?:D

Because ER is one of the best games I've ever played!
Its great. I think the best thing about it is so many of these casual fans will go back and play their older titles after Elden Ring.

And those older titles still hold up so well.

So many getting to experience these type of games for the first time makes me happy. There has been a few people here on meta who have done lttp with those old titles already.
 

low-G

old school cool
Nov 1, 2018
914
1,748
93
So, those of you who've been souls lovers since day one, how do you feel now that ER has so many casual fans? Are you hipster bitter ?:D

Because ER is one of the best games I've ever played!
As someone that has been on since King's Field, and was one of those Demon's Souls importer hype-men, I'm super happy it has come so far without yet sacrificing the core stuff I love about it. I'm more hipster proud.
 

LEANIJA

MetaMember
May 5, 2019
3,254
7,951
113
Austria
So, those of you who've been souls lovers since day one, how do you feel now that ER has so many casual fans? Are you hipster bitter ?:D

Because ER is one of the best games I've ever played!
I never could get into Souls-like games so I cant speak from that, but I got a friend who loves those games to bits and talks about them a LOT, and he is VERY happy I am playing Elden Ring :D
 
  • Gib
  • Like
Reactions: Le Pertti and QFNS

SaberVS7

Average Date a Live Enjoyer
Jan 23, 2020
239
765
93
Anyone else having a problem with invaders using Carian Retaliation? It seems there's a bug going around in the latest patch that allows it to be used as an effectively undodgeable instant-kill.
 
  • Sad
Reactions: Panda Pedinte

low-G

old school cool
Nov 1, 2018
914
1,748
93
Late game boss rant:

Malenia's lifesteal completely ruins the fight and makes her unfun. I like her patterns, but the lifesteal mechanic is just terrible.
I beat that boss today. I don't know how people with a different build than me would handle it.

My 'strategy'
Key for me was HIGH armor (donning all the max armor I've literally found so far, under medium load), so my silver tear clone boy would survive the entire fight, and just getting lucky with us stun locking her... probably took me ~25 attempts. I tried with a light load and my clone died really quickly (P.S. clone is at +10)

I dual weild (for most of the game), so 4 attacks coming at her in rapid succession at times really dominates. (+25 and +23 uchigatana)
 
  • Like
Reactions: Panda Pedinte

QFNS

Plays too many card games
Nov 18, 2018
1,308
3,153
113
I finally beat her. I straight up had to cheese it by respeccing to a full DEX build, using Rivers of Blood and a summon, but after 5 hours of grinding it, I am beyond the point of caring.

Fuck what anyone calls "cheese" in these games IMO. Did you beat it? You win. These games are hard enough without needing to accept other people's definitions of what "counts".

Use those summons, respec, find every broken spell or weapon in the game. They put it there to be used. ESPECIALLY in PvE content who cares what anyone does? Let people get the W in whatever way they want.

I'm not there yet but I'm probably getting close. Not excited to see how badly I get my behind whipped.
 

Avern

MetaMember
May 14, 2020
370
1,239
93
The changes they made to how stuns work in this game are sooooo good.

In every Fromsoft game, my intended build gets thrown out the window the moment I get an ultra greatsword. But here, using an ultra greatsword practically feels like a new build. Figuring out when and where I can go for charged R2's and jump attacks is fun, and if a boss isn't doing enough damage to really scare me, I can do some pretty degenerate stuff to get through the fight.

Truly summons, ashes, and magic are all easy mode compared to my colossal, big-brain strat of spamming jumping R2. You can't even imagine the genius required to press L2, facetank the enemy's attack, and stun them with Lion's Claw. 🧠🧠🧠

People whining about how things like magic are easy mode has always been dumb, but it seems even dumber in Elden Ring where I can get away with nonsense like this.
 

fearthedawn

MetaMember
Apr 19, 2019
313
633
93
I finally killed Malenia yesterday and it came down to killing her faster than she killed me by maximizing every opportunity to get damage in, still don't know how to properly dodge that one move. Thankfully my dual curved swords can dish out tons of damage really quickly, i was even considering respeccing to weaken myself before getting to this area of the game because everything just died.

The hardest fight in the game so far is the rotten erdtree avatar with its two healing knight buddies in front of a door though, i got stubborn about it, refused to sneak around and took them head on and oh boy, not a good decision for my blood pressure.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Panda Pedinte
Dec 5, 2018
1,763
4,358
113
Souls games are always about cheesing your way through.

I started using the Mimic Tear recently and it's pretty broken add to that my dual katana set up (poison + bleed) and if the boss is weak to either they get inflicted fast.

I'm in the area where you fight Melenia, I'm a bit scared reading your horror stories but we'll see.

Also another achivement glitched the one for getting all the legendary weapons. I found a lame way to get it leave all the legendary weapons and pick them back up.
 

LEANIJA

MetaMember
May 5, 2019
3,254
7,951
113
Austria
I just horribly murdered Radahn ... I heard hes hard but I might just be overlevelled now, as soon as I actually managed to get my bearings and dodge his spears, summon all the helpers, I beat him on first try.

edit: technically it was probably 5 tries altogether, but the first few ended very quickly – as i said, as soon as I got a hold of whats going on, it was fast. but Im also level 80 now, so... overlevelled surely.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Panda Pedinte

fearthedawn

MetaMember
Apr 19, 2019
313
633
93
I just horribly murdered Radahn ... I heard hes hard but I might just be overlevelled now, as soon as I actually managed to get my bearings and dodge his spears, summon all the helpers, I beat him on first try.

edit: technically it was probably 5 tries altogether, but the first few ended very quickly – as i said, as soon as I got a hold of whats going on, it was fast. but Im also level 80 now, so... overlevelled surely.
Similar experience for me, quickly went from "clearly this is a fight designed for having summons, let's get some" to "maybe i shouldn't have because this turned out to be entirely underwhelming"...

pretty sure the warnings about a hard fight came from the "never summons" crowd that got there lower in level
 

EdwardTivrusky

Good Morning, Weather Hackers!
Dec 8, 2018
7,447
12,579
113
I am definitely overlevelled from exploring so much yet I am still a glass cannon that will get 1-hit by boss or bigger enemies or stunlocked by low-level mobs easily but if i can survive a hit and then roll like a maniac away from the boss i can usually get a couple of good Rock Slings in before running away again. I also seem to have one of the really good summons which helps as poor ol' jellyfish was starting to get wrecked more quickly.

I also have no problem being overlevelled for bosses and also cheesing them especially those huge Rune Bear things. I'll happily cheese those all day long as they mess me up easily if they get close or stun me with the shouty thing they do. Assholes.
 
Last edited:

Panda Pedinte

Best Sig Maker on the board!
Sep 20, 2018
4,975
13,724
113
I just horribly murdered Radahn ... I heard hes hard but I might just be overlevelled now, as soon as I actually managed to get my bearings and dodge his spears, summon all the helpers, I beat him on first try.

edit: technically it was probably 5 tries altogether, but the first few ended very quickly – as i said, as soon as I got a hold of whats going on, it was fast. but Im also level 80 now, so... overlevelled surely.
Similar experience for me, quickly went from "clearly this is a fight designed for having summons, let's get some" to "maybe i shouldn't have because this turned out to be entirely underwhelming"...

pretty sure the warnings about a hard fight came from the "never summons" crowd that got there lower in level
His difficult was toned down a bit in one of the patches, though the hardest part for me pre patch was avoiding his meteors.
 
  • Like
Reactions: LEANIJA and QFNS
OP
Durante

Durante

I <3 Pixels
Oct 21, 2018
4,082
19,693
113
Yesterday I got my first legendary sorcery, which then apparently also unlocked progress in Sellen's quest. I've been waiting for that to happen for something like 100 in-game hours, so I was really hyped and continued for a while more. Now I have another legendary sorcery, and this one actually seems useful rather than just silly!

I also found the (weapon) Wing of Astel a bit earlier and now use it as my melee/fallback weapon. I'm not really specced into Dex but I love the moveset, so I'm using the Dex talisman to be able to wield it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: QFNS

Li Kao

It’s a strange world. Let’s keep it that way.
Jan 28, 2019
7,906
16,001
113
I'm at the sorcery school and wow its hard! That mother fucker with those magic arrows sucks so bad!
I don't remember that motherfucker. I remember plenty of motherfuckers in the school, but magic arrows ? You mean the wizards with stone face ?
 

Le Pertti

0.01% Game dev
Oct 10, 2018
8,696
22,411
113
45
Paris, France
lepertti.com
I don't remember that motherfucker. I remember plenty of motherfuckers in the school, but magic arrows ? You mean the wizards with stone face ?
Hmh don't think he has a stone face, but he has a bow and everything!

Edit, no wait maybe its not the school, but it is like a library, doesn't seem to be too big. Carian Study Hall.
This one! I'm always so close to beat him but he constantly teleports.


(not my pic)
 
Last edited:

Li Kao

It’s a strange world. Let’s keep it that way.
Jan 28, 2019
7,906
16,001
113
Hmh don't think he has a stone face, but he has a bow and everything!

Edit, no wait maybe its not the school, but it is like a library, doesn't seem to be too big. Carian Study Hall.
This one! I'm always so close to beat him but he constantly teleports.
Ohhhh, that one is a bitch.
I cheesed her with ranged weapon and just enough space to shoot I think.

edit - obviously not in the first phase of the fight where it's a little crowded.
And at the risk of being spoilery, I think I cheesed her
the second time
 
Last edited:
  • Eyes
  • Like
Reactions: QFNS and Le Pertti

Panda Pedinte

Best Sig Maker on the board!
Sep 20, 2018
4,975
13,724
113
Hmh don't think he has a stone face, but he has a bow and everything!

Edit, no wait maybe its not the school, but it is like a library, doesn't seem to be too big. Carian Study Hall.
This one! I'm always so close to beat him but he constantly teleports.


(not my pic)
She is so annoying with the teleporting bullshit.
 

Alextended

Segata's Disciple
Jan 28, 2019
5,750
8,999
113
It's a fun difference from other fights in the game and feels awesome when you get it down. But yeah even with my full STR build I had to use ranged weapons a lot for at least some damage & really understand how the AI behaves, when it prepares to shoot and how it throws teleportation in to not dodge my stuff etc. They could easily make it unfair by not having rails and what not that basically protect you every phase from her spells while you deal with the minions first. I still took a ton of damage as I went there rather early the first time around and even my best anti-magic gear didn't seem to reduce it much at all.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: QFNS

Panda Pedinte

Best Sig Maker on the board!
Sep 20, 2018
4,975
13,724
113
I started a new character, I choose Wretch so it has been an interesting experience starting the game with basically nothing. The only other souls game that I did it was in DS2.
 
  • Like
Reactions: QFNS

QFNS

Plays too many card games
Nov 18, 2018
1,308
3,153
113
Yesterday I got my first legendary sorcery, which then apparently also unlocked progress in Sellen's quest. I've been waiting for that to happen for something like 100 in-game hours, so I was really hyped and continued for a while more. Now I have another legendary sorcery, and this one actually seems useful rather than just silly!

I also found the (weapon) Wing of Astel a bit earlier and now use it as my melee/fallback weapon. I'm not really specced into Dex but I love the moveset, so I'm using the Dex talisman to be able to wield it.
Yes!!! I have been wanting to have a talk about this weapon and this is a good opportunity!

Wing of Astel RULES. The R2 produces a really nice projectile. The charged R2 does 2 projectiles back to back! Neither move costs any FP! Amazing. The combo for the curved sword has more hits than the katana (ye olde Moonveil) too which can be really handy in keeping the pressure on when you find an opening.

The weapon art has multiple hits too, but is harder to hit with due to the arc it creates. That said though you can really knock around enemies if you catch them in the arc. It also can hit small groups if you time it right.

Only real downside is the shorter range on the blade vs something longer like Moonveil. I have been using it quite a lot (at +8 ATM), and alternate between it and a thrusting sword and a (poorly upgraded) flail or something for enemies that need Strike damage and somehow resist magic.

Also finding it is pretty annoying. Moonveil is much easier to get and you can get it earlier. Wing of Astel is a worthy successor however if you can deal with the shorter range.
 

Le Pertti

0.01% Game dev
Oct 10, 2018
8,696
22,411
113
45
Paris, France
lepertti.com
So I beat the magic bow type, but now I'm not sure what there is to do in the tower. I can see stairs but can't get to them and can't find what one is supposed to do. No hints in messages either. BUT it is a good spot to farm, quick runs that give 5000, not too bad.
 
  • Like
Reactions: QFNS

Alextended

Segata's Disciple
Jan 28, 2019
5,750
8,999
113
Just loot whatever you can in all currently accesible areas (via ladder also at one point before the wizard's final stand area) and that's all there is, for now.
 
  • Like
Reactions: QFNS and Le Pertti

sprinkles

Junior Member
Dec 8, 2018
627
1,212
93
So I beat the magic bow type, but now I'm not sure what there is to do in the tower. I can see stairs but can't get to them and can't find what one is supposed to do. No hints in messages either. BUT it is a good spot to farm, quick runs that give 5000, not too bad.
You come back way later to that tower during Rannie's questline
 
  • Eyes
  • Like
Reactions: QFNS and Le Pertti

kio

MetaMember
Apr 19, 2019
1,634
5,250
113
So I beat the magic bow type, but now I'm not sure what there is to do in the tower. I can see stairs but can't get to them and can't find what one is supposed to do. No hints in messages either. BUT it is a good spot to farm, quick runs that give 5000, not too bad.
You did a couple of things out of order as you didn't need to go there until much later (you'll almost surely lack a key item). Just explore the map. Liurnia is a great place.