So the more I play the Jedi the more I sort of feel bad for it. Is it a "good" game? Oh yes very much so. Does it have issues? It does and some of the issues might just have to do with the situation of EA/Respawn and most importantly of Disney. Does Disney really care about Star Wars game? I have my doubts. Does Disney care about Marvel games I have my doubts.
Now let's look at Star Wars vs Marvel. Both of these have been around for a very long time but it was not until 2012 or so that Disney bought both Star Wars and Marvel. Prior to Disney buying both of those IPs multiple companies (including Lucasarts) were making Star Wars game, the same can be said for Marvel stuff. But after Disney purchased Star Wars stuff changed. With Star Wars they gave EA the 10 year exclusive license (with some exceptions it would seem since the Lego Star Wars games still do exist and those are done through WB who owns TT, and well LEGO Star Wars prints money so Disney would not get rid of that) so since 2013 or so the only Star Wars games that we have gotten are basically the Battlefront games and even then they were not that great. Then you look at Marvel those also had games made by different companies prior to the purchase but the difference is that that series didn't get an exclusivity deal made. Is that because there is more of a "rich history" with Star Wars game compared to Marvel games? The only Marvel games that I recall that people have really liked are the NES X-Men game, Marvel VS Capcom games, and Spider-Man 2 game.
So in more recent year EA has Star Wars and both DICE and Respawn have made games with the IP, others were also set to make games as well but those games were cancelled/studios shutdown.
Now if we look at Marvel you have different devs making games with those IPs, there was the Insomniac Spider-Man game, the SE Avengers game, Marvel VS Capcom Infinite, and the KT Avengers Musou game thing. This is course is not even looking at mobile games.
Of the EA games, it seems that a lot of money was poured into the Battlefront games and that they even got a lot of PR, but then you look at the Jedi game and ya they didn't really seem to do that with the game and you can tell from playing the game as well.
Then you look at Marvel stuff, a lot of money and time was poured into Spider-Man (hell I think there were even talks of Sony maybe getting the exclusive rights to Marvel games which I hope does not happen). The KT game did get some coverage and stuff but it kind of came and went. And of course the SE Avengers game, so far that game does not look that good and it seems like SE is giving better treatment to that came compared to what EA did with Jedi. EA does not like Respawn.
I'm not sure if the Avengers game will be getting this or if the Spider-man game got this but I know for a fact that Battlefront 2 did get coverage by ABC here in the US. By which I mean they did an Interview with the person from the campaign of the game and asked her questions about the game. Doing stuff like that is not something that most games do.
So with all of that said it makes sense why expectations for Jedi were pretty low, this meant that the bar that Jedi had to pass in order to be liked by people was not that high seeing how we have gone years with out a "good" Star Wars game that people really liked.
The Jedi game does feel like a quality game but I'm sure that those that have played have felt that the game had limitations and that it's not nearly as poslish compared to say if it was the Insomniac Spider-Man game. The animations and stuff feel off in the game (you do get use to them later) oh and I've come across a number of issues with in the game, example include rag dolls, jumping and just physics in general.
This feels like a AA game at best. Its no where near the quality of a AAA game (and that includes AAA games that have game breaking bugs). While a AAA game may have game breaking bugs there are certain things that make them feel like a AAA game.
I wonder how much they could have improved the game had they given it a much larger budget and faith behind the game. Because its' limits do stick out at times. The way you Interact with some objects just feels off, where you can't even "touch" certain things and they feel like they have an invisible force field around them. Take the ship as an example try to climb it, you can't and the issue is the way it feels when you try to "touch" it.
I'm done complaining for now
---
----
The SE game will likely get more cover than the Jedi game ever did. The Jedi game will likely end up selling more copies than Avengers and have a much higher user and critic review score.
And Jedi may end up being the only EA game on EGS.