Regarding Fallout (saw all 8 episodes):
When Bethesda acquired the IP and decided to set their games on the east coast, I was like, great, they can do what they want in their playground, even if they mess up the lore, they cannot do too much harm since it is across the continent.
And then they decided to set this TV show on west coast...place of Fallout 1, Fallout 2 and New Vegas. So I was both excited (I will see NCR! and maybe some other locations I know and love!) and apprehensive (they will fuck it up, won't they? This is hollywood after all!).
Well,
If I never played original games and only started with FO3, I would probably be a pretty big fan of the show.
Technically, the show is well made - mostly good actors (especially Goggins and Purnell), good CGI, good pacing. Script is hit and miss, some really questionable character behavior and some plot holes, the way they made BoS knight utterly pathetic was lame, etc, but overall, it is a fun watch.
But yeah their treatment of original game's setting is kinda unforgivable for me, to the point where I am tempted to write it off as (personal) non-canon, eventhough I had fun watching it. Quite paradoxical.
When Bethesda acquired the IP and decided to set their games on the east coast, I was like, great, they can do what they want in their playground, even if they mess up the lore, they cannot do too much harm since it is across the continent.
And then they decided to set this TV show on west coast...place of Fallout 1, Fallout 2 and New Vegas. So I was both excited (I will see NCR! and maybe some other locations I know and love!) and apprehensive (they will fuck it up, won't they? This is hollywood after all!).
Well,
I did not expect them to literally obliterate the setting of games I grew up with in nuclear fire and effectively set their development to pre-Fallout 1 level, I can tell you that.
If I never played original games and only started with FO3, I would probably be a pretty big fan of the show.
Technically, the show is well made - mostly good actors (especially Goggins and Purnell), good CGI, good pacing. Script is hit and miss, some really questionable character behavior and some plot holes, the way they made BoS knight utterly pathetic was lame, etc, but overall, it is a fun watch.
But yeah their treatment of original game's setting is kinda unforgivable for me, to the point where I am tempted to write it off as (personal) non-canon, eventhough I had fun watching it. Quite paradoxical.