Was this game bad or what
They had solid combat, and really good character customization.
The problem was with everything else, where they constantly revamped progression, class and weapon design, social activities (that were super barebones), the level design sucked, the encounter design mostly sucked, they had almost no content...
It's not unlike PSO2 New Genesis really, but even worse.
Worst thing is, I played what was possibly the technical alpha in like... 2018. They had something with potential, but never managing to put out anything complete has been a huge problem for Japanese GaaS and they just get taken over by Korean and Chinese games.
It's one of reasons why the fabled "lazy dev rhetoric" is false - not because they aren't lazy, but because they're incompetent.
On another note, I find the Trails in the Sky remake to look.. mostly dreadful.
Models are nice, but definitely not as expressive as 2D portraits, and when I think modern remake 20 years later I don't think this:
Not even remotely an upgrade in my eyes, quite the opposite, all the charm of the top down camera angles with sprites is gone, and you have a middling PS3 game in its place... I much prefer the old one (and Kai came with improvements too, even if we never got it you can cobble it together on PC):