To expand upon Black Geyser.
Well, here are the first impressions I'm talking about (but if you don't speak French, enter at your own peril, I tested it and Youtube auto translate is an industrial accident here).
Highlight: Black Geyser: Couriers of Darkness (accès anticipé) - YouTube
The man is a former writer at Gamekult, pretty good outlet in its time, and he... does not really do PR speak or diplomacy. His Fallout 76 was something, with the game crashing and burning before he could even play. A video with lots of laughs and expletives. I'm trying to introduce the character and his lack of diplomacy.
His final take on Black Geyser :
"Honestly, I will stop there on Black Geyser CoD.
I am convinced that the game is probably more interesting later, but as I always say, later is too late. Because it has been what, 1h30 that I have been playing it and I'm falling asleep in front of so much emptiness and generic stuff. So, it's very cool to want to make an old fashioned crpg like that, with very clear inspirations that maybe go a little too far beyond the simple tribute, to BG1, but... we are bored shitless in your game, guys, and we really shouldn't, during the first hour of a video game, whatever the game might be.
If I'm bored during the first hour I won't play a second one. And that's more or less the issue here. So I understand that the game is in EA, and I understand that this kind of game, probably my favorite genre, asks for a lot more than one hour of play to be evaluated, but I have rarely seen an intro so damn boring, for fuck's sake. And then the plot is hyper generic. I'm sorry but nowadays I expect more from a crpg than a oh my god the xxx killed the xxx and the father turned out to be xxx and 'wow, it was so surprising' that I could see all of it coming before it happened.
So yeah, not convinced by this BG CoD. I'm very able to forgive a lot to this genre, technically and even artistically because it's a genre I adore, but something has to be done faster and more efficiently to convince me here.
Instead of making me waste my time in such a pronounced way."
-> So yeah, I'm not totally on board with all his points, but the man has spent several lifetimes on Pathfinder KM and WoTR, so I tend to take his opinion into account. Let's say that I'm wary here.